A 500% More Effective Blog Commenting Strategy

by Joe B. on May 30, 2012

Post image for A 500% More Effective Blog Commenting Strategy

Blog commenting always has been, and most likely always will be, one of the most effective ways to generate traffic to your website. It’s so simple, and anybody can do it.

There’s a problem, though – many go about it in the wrong manner. Much like most things in life, there’s a right and a wrong way to go about it.

Luckily, though, it’s extremely easy to improve your strategy and create massive amounts of traffic with just a fraction of your time per week.

Effective Strategies

Create a List

When it comes to writing comments on blogs, you have two main purposes:

Whether digital or manually written, a list is a must!
  • Implant yourself into the community
  • Benefit from the community

To become a major part of a community, repetition is a major key – leaving just one comment on a blog in its life span most likely will not do you much good.

The truth about effectively commenting on blogs is to plaster yourself – without spamming – onto the blog. Your goal is to get the members of the community and blog owner to know you.

How can you repetitively comment on new posts of blogs? Build a list, of course!

At the time of this writing, my list of blogs that I comment on peaks at about 100. Checking them manually would be a pain. Luckily, however, there are tools to simplify the procedure:

Engage With The Community Via Quality Comments

There’s a good reason why spam comments are so ineffective when it comes to a blog comment strategy – they lack the quality needed to be successful.

Whenever I comment on a blog, I spend three or four minutes reading the article, another three or four minutes writing my own comment, and then some more time replying to others.

Keep community-readers from becoming bored by engaging with them.

While writing “Great post!” might help the author’s self esteem, it won’t do a thing for your traffic.

Your comments should be viewed as an extension of the post. It should provide value to the reader, and furthermore encourage the community to visit your website.

In my original comment, I am sure to, in a nutshell, leave a direct reply to the author. This is the one-on-one time – it’s generally the most valuable.

These comments should be well structured, and generally will go over well with everybody.

I also reply to comments outside of the one-on-one conversation between the author and myself. A strong sense of community generally pulls over well.

Expand Your List

You create a list of ten blogs that you religiously comment on, carefully leaving powerful comments on a daily basis. Traffic soars as the community begins to fall in love with you.

Suddenly, your referral traffic flattens. What gives?

One blog can only supply so much referral traffic to you – eventually you will need to tap into more blogs. Thus, we need to expand our lists.

It’s really simple to expand your list – I generally add four or eight new blogs per day, allowing a huge growth over time. Luckily, it’s as easy as a few steps:

  1. Use Google Analytics to track websites that refer traffic to your website.
  2. Find your top referring blogs (I generally choose my top two).
  3. Find referring blogs that result in very high time-on-site/low bound-rate factors.
  4. Find commentators of the selected blogs in your niche and add them to your list.

Not every commentator of a blog you follow will be in your niche, but a considerable chunk will – make use of them and engage with their communities.

As your list grows, the incoming traffic does as well. It’s quiet magical.

What Commenting Strategies Do You Use?

Photo Credit: Thumbnail | List | Reader

Did you learn from this article?

Our countless newsletter subscribers did, too, and depend on WebsiteBegin's bi-monthly newsletter to learn cutting-edge tips and tricks to improve their websites... You should join them.

{ 13 comments… read them below or add one }

Great Post ;-)

Hopefully I lifted your self esteem!

Reply

Haha, that’s probably the most relevant (or irrelevant?) comment on a post I’ve seen in a long time (; I know I said these comments won’t help you in your strategy, but you just earned yourself a visit (;

Self esteem lifted!

Reply

Reading a post with the intention to comment on it actually changes how you process the information. Instead of just passively reading, your mind actually starts to critique and analyze. So you get an extra benefit :) .

Reply

Sometimes disagreeing can be helpful when writing a blog comment. Unless everybody agrees and the topic is common sense (there is no opposition, there is only one correct view), your opposing comment could attract far more visits then those who just say “GREAT POST I AGREE!”. It’s pretty cool how our brain processes things, isn’t it?

Reply

Thanks for being a “dofollow” blog. Blog commenting is also a great way to add a little bit more to the post or offer a different perspective and engage with others.

Reply

Great point – DoFollow really does help with not only getting comments, but also gaining extra traffic because of the SEO value!

Reply

Great idea, but a 1000% more effective commenting strategy would be to only comment when you can add value to the blog post. I’m sure you do this, but some of your readers might misunderstand. Quality over quantity is golden. Might be slower but much more effective. Low quality comments is annoying and I hate them, I often delete them. Some of the regular posters on blogs like SEOmoz only post crap and I think it harms the community.

Reply

Everything in today’s world revolves around quality. It’s that simple. If you are releasing terrible content (and remember, comments are technically content, too), you can’t honestly expect anything positive to result from your efforts. My filter systems practically deter any spammy-comments, so my community is safe (;

Reply

Great post, Joe. I think blog commenting is an underestimated strategy (done correctly and white-hat).

I have an interesting case study for you. A fellow SEO said he could get 30 blog comments in one hour, using Scrapebox (bleugh!), while I chose instead to take the honest, ethical approach and submit blog comments properly – having read each post and submitting a quality comment – but I was only able to do 4 blog comments in the same space of time. What was interesting though (although probably quite obvious as well) was that while all 4 of mine went live, only 1 of his 30 did! Not only that, but one of my comments must’ve impressed the blog owner, as I also got a guest blogging offer from one of them!

Just goes to show that quality trumps quantity, and – in this case – results in more actual quantity anyway! You’ve got to take time to build quality. Take the easy/lazy route and not only are you breaking Google’s guidelines, but you’re wasting your time, anyway!

Reply

It’s kind of like the guys who spend thousands of dollars on getting hundreds of thousands of backlinks. Yeah, you have them. But what value are they of? It hurts you more (especially with recent Google updates) to have those purchased backlinks in quantities of thousands, then to have a few backlinks that are legitimate.

The cool thing about having legitimate comments on blog posts is that they not only result in short-term visits from readers and the author, but can easily result in long-term traffic from SEO. I know plenty of websites that achieved a PR of two or higher from guest articles and blog commenting. It’s really magical.

Reply

Yeah….it is the best way to make more traffic to your website and giving him to rank more as the more back links. But you have to make them at the do follow sites then the back links become more attractive and useful.

Reply

That’s the beauty of blog commenting – DoFollow blogs give you the benefit of returning traffic in the form of search engine results later on down the road!

Reply

My partner and I stumbled over here coming from a different website and thought I should check things out.

I like what I see so i am just following you. Look
forward to going over your web page repeatedly.
Josephine recently posted..JosephineMy Profile

Reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

Previous post:

Next post: